Documentary review performed by Codex on November 11, 2026. These examples remain untested in an account. Represent consent criteria through documented properties and handle missing values separately; the property documentation notes that some negative text filters omit them. Referencing another segment remains an unestablished construction in the pages consulted. This post presents documentary analysis and screening examples.
What the law calls consent, and what Klaviyo knows about it
Section 6 of CASL prohibits sending a commercial electronic message unless the person has consented to receive it, expressly or impliedly, and the message meets the prescribed form: identification of the sender, a way to contact them, and an unsubscribe mechanism. A message that contains a request for consent to send commercial messages is itself considered a commercial electronic message (section 1, subsection 3). And a person who alleges that they have consent has the onus of proving it (section 13).
Express consent carries no expiry date: Klaviyo writes that, under CASL, it does not expire but the person can withdraw it at any time. Implied consent is different. For the purposes of section 6, except subsection 6(7.1), subsection 10(9) limits the circumstances supporting implied consent. These include an existing business relationship, whose definition in subsection 10(10) sets the windows examined here.
On the Klaviyo side, the "Understanding explicit vs. implicit consent" page specifies that "Never subscribed" means the profile has neither opted in nor opted out of email marketing, and that this status does not establish legally valid implied consent: the applicable rules must be checked before emailing those contacts. It adds that a subscribed profile can still be suppressed (after a hard bounce, for example), and that consent and suppression must be checked on the profile before sending. In the two consent help pages we read, which do say that implied consent can expire, no passage describes a status that changes by itself after two years. In our view, that is the source of the trap: a list can look in order in the interface and no longer be so under the law.
Klaviyo recommends obtaining express consent whenever possible, keeping a separate list for contacts with implied consent, and trying to obtain their express consent. SMS and MMS require express consent in Klaviyo.
The two clocks of section 10
Subsection 10(10) covers the recipient’s relationship with the sender or with a person who causes or permits the message to be sent. In the following list, “sender” refers to any of those persons. The relationship arises from any of the following:
- the purchase or lease by the person of a product, goods, a service, land or an interest or right in land from the sender within the two-year period immediately before the day on which the message was sent;
- the acceptance by the person, within that period, of a business, investment or gaming opportunity offered by the sender;
- the bartering, between those persons and within that period, of anything mentioned in paragraph (a);
- a written contract, still in existence or expired within that period, in respect of a matter not covered by the preceding points;
- an inquiry or application made to the sender within the six-month period immediately before the day on which the message was sent, in respect of a thing or opportunity mentioned in paragraphs (a) or (c) in the French version of the Act, and in paragraphs (a) to (c) in the English version, which in the French version means a purchase, a lease or a barter; the English version adds the acceptance of a business, investment or gaming opportunity.
Two further points of the same section matter for a store. First, the periods in subsection 10(10) are defined relative to the day on which each message is sent. Second, subsection 10(14) provides that, for ongoing use or ongoing purchase under a subscription, account, loan or similar relationship, the period begins on the day that the subscription, account, loan or relationship terminates.
The list in subsection 10(10) mentions neither opening an email, nor a click, nor a site visit. In our view, an engagement event alone is insufficient to qualify an action. Distinguish open or click tracking from a qualifying inquiry or a documented opt-in.
Turning the clocks into Klaviyo segments
The Klaviyo references consulted describe relative event periods in hours, days and weeks, calculated in UTC. For an active segment, activity can change membership when processed; changes caused solely by elapsed time are processed once every 24 hours. Inactive segments stop updating and need reactivation before membership updates can be relied on. The 700-day and 150-day thresholds are documentary screening choices, distinct from calendar deadlines. Boundary behaviour still needs verification.
These four groups illustrate documentary screening, supplemented by assessment of the data, withdrawals and applicable grounds.
- Express-consent record to review. A property can identify retained evidence. Also assess current consent and suppression statuses.
- Recent purchase to review. Example: a Placed Order event recorded at least once in 700 days. Check its origin and meaning. The email-reception filter describes product eligibility; legal qualification needs separate assessment.
- Recent inquiry to assess. A custom event recorded in 150 days can identify records. Retain the substance of the action for assessment. A form submission or abandoned cart needs qualification, followed by checks for withdrawals and suppressions.
- Outside the screening thresholds. Example: no recorded purchase in 700 days AND no recorded inquiry in 150 days. Add the selected documentary criteria and explicit handling of missing data. The result calls for record review.
Segments 2 to 4 are rolling windows: do not replace them with a frozen list exported on a given day, which does not update.
The messages you can still send to an expired profile
Subsection 6(6) removes the consent requirement for messages that solely, as the case may be, fall into one of the following (the Act's list also covers employment-related information and purposes specified in the regulations): provide a quote or estimate requested by the person; facilitate, complete or confirm a commercial transaction the recipient previously agreed to enter into with the sender or the person on whose behalf the message is sent; provide warranty, product recall, or safety or security information about a product, goods or service that the recipient uses, has used or has purchased; provide factual information about the recipient’s ongoing use or purchase of goods or services offered under a subscription, membership, account, loan or similar relationship by the sender or the person represented, or about that ongoing relationship; or deliver goods, a product or a service, including updates or upgrades, that the recipient is entitled to receive under a transaction previously entered into with the sender or the person represented. The word "solely" matters: an order confirmation email that also contains a promotion no longer falls within the exception. Klaviyo says it in its own way: purely transactional messages, without promotional content, are exempt from the consent requirement, but not from the identification and unsubscribe requirements.
The re-permission sequence
A consent request falls within commercial messaging. Assess the basis applicable at send time, including relevant exceptions. The 640-day reference leaves 60 days before the editorial threshold of 700 days. Triggering from the latest purchase needs verification of subsequent purchases, re-entry and checks before sending. Section 10(1) and section 4 of the CRTC Regulations require the purposes, the requester’s identity and any person represented, their respective roles, a mailing address with either a telephone number providing access to a service agent or a voice messaging system, or an email or web address, and a statement about withdrawing consent. In our view, when the person consents, retaining the date, source and exact wording in an evidence record linked to the profile is a useful way to address the onus of proof.
What the law provides in case of a breach
The text of the Act (last amended January 1, 2026) sets the maximum administrative monetary penalty per violation at $1,000,000 for an individual and $10,000,000 for any other person (section 20, subsection 4), and specifies that the purpose of a penalty is to promote compliance, not to punish (subsection 2). Officers, directors, agents or mandataries of a corporation who directed, authorized, assented to, acquiesced in or participated in the violation are liable for it (section 31). Section 33 provides that a person must not be found liable for a violation if they establish that they exercised due diligence to prevent it: in our view, dated segments and proof of consent also serve that purpose.
The private right of action appears in sections 47 to 51. In the consolidated text we read, each of those sections carries the mention "Repealed before coming into force". We did not look for the origin of the reference "2008, c. 20, s. 3" that accompanies that mention.
A five-step list audit
- Define the recipients and flows to review, including technically reachable profiles without subscribed status.
- Match evidence, events, withdrawals and suppressions; use the four groups as screening aids.
- In our view, review past sends using their recipients and the evidence available at each send date; current membership does not reconstruct that history.
- Assess sending criteria and transactional-message content against the basis relied on.
- Describe and test the proposed sequence before scheduling it, then date the next review.
The overall framework of the rules that touch an ad account is on the page advertising compliance in Québec and Canada. The neighbouring Law 25 obligations are in Privacy policy and advertising under Québec Law 25 and in Meta pixel and Law 25: a four-step Shopify test. Our work on Klaviyo, consent included, is described on the page Klaviyo agency in Montréal.